Again with the Pussycat Dolls

Let me understand this - you have 4 people left. One person admittedly can't dance and they have a horrible solo performance. Another has a strong performance and is a really good dancer. You decide to keep the non-dancer because the other is "generic"? Meanwhile, the only thing non-generic about the non-dancer is her backstory?

(Yes, I know that I already said they were setting Asia up for the win. And yes, I know that this is basic storytelling: the bad person - Melissa S. - mocks the good person - Chelsea - only to get her comeupance. But still, come on now.)